Expert AI training work is following the pay pattern of global data labour
Yale researcher Julián Posada argues that platforms recruiting doctors, lawyers and PhDs to train AI pay well at first, then cut rates and drop workers, as they did in Venezuela and Kenya.
Outlier, a recruiting platform run by Scale AI, advertises rates of up to $180 an hour for U.S. physicians to design cardiac scenarios, review AI-generated reports and rank model outputs. For the same job, it lists up to $7.50 an hour for Tagalog work in the Philippines and up to $12.50 an hour for Swahili in Tanzania.
Those figures open an opinion essay in Rest of World by Julián Posada, an assistant professor at Yale University and author of "Platform Extractivism: Data Work and the People Powering Artificial Intelligence." His argument is that AI is not so much replacing expert jobs as moving parts of them onto platforms with the same conditions that low-paid data workers have dealt with for years. Higher credentials raise the advertised rate. The platform still controls payment and working conditions.
A pattern documented in Venezuela and Kenya
Posada says he has spent six years interviewing data workers, most of them in Venezuela. One of them, Rogelio, had taught computer science until the economic crisis and the pandemic left his family without work. His 13-year-old son found they could label images of cars and roads on Hive and on Scale AI's Remotasks, using a laptop the Hugo Chávez government had issued to schoolchildren a decade earlier. The boy earned 18 cents for a few hours. Rogelio earned just over $2 on his first day.
For a while the work paid. A task called Beast Mode, in which workers labelled objects in people's homes, brought the family $20 in a single day in December 2020, with schools closed and everyone working. That was the most they would ever make. By early 2021 the task was gone, and their earnings fell below Hive's $5 weekly payout threshold.
Posada describes this as the standard cycle: pay well to build a workforce, then cut rates and move on. Remotasks ended its hourly program in Venezuela in 2021 and expanded in Kenya the same year. In March 2024 it discontinued operations in Kenya, Nigeria and Pakistan. Scale AI attributed the closures to "enhanced security protocols" and said notices went out three weeks ahead. It later acknowledged that Kenyan workers never received them "due to operational errors."
He calls the pattern extractivism: value taken from people and places on terms set by the buyer. The difference from an oil economy, he writes, is mobility. An oil field stays put. A platform can send the next batch of tasks somewhere else.
The same terms, now for professionals
Posada points to the contract language. Outlier's terms let the company delay or suspend payment while it investigates a worker's tasks, and withhold "some or all amounts accrued" where it finds a violation "in the company's sole determination." It may deactivate an account "immediately without prior notice for any reason." According to Posada, the same wording appeared word for word in the Remotasks terms that Rogelio's family worked under in 2021.
He cites reporting from earlier this year by Josh Dzieza on laid-off lawyers, scientists and screenwriters now working on these platforms. Of more than 30 workers interviewed, nearly all described the same arc: demands rose, target times shrank and pay fell as a project went on. One designer was tagging videos for Meta at $21 an hour when the project ended for "scope changes." Days later the same job reappeared under a new name at $16 an hour.
Workers can leave, and many do. Posada notes that those who stay are often those who cannot. One woman he interviewed, confined to her home during the Covid-19 pandemic by a health condition, told him: "This is my only source of income."
Responsibility and the courts
Posada describes a 2024 meeting convened by the nonprofit Partnership on AI and the Fairwork project, with AI companies and the outsourcing firms that supply them. In his account, the AI companies said they did not employ the data workers, and the outsourcing firms said their operations were set by the prices AI companies expected. Everyone agreed pay should be better. No workers were present.
Some disputes have reached courts. In March 2023 a judge in Kenya temporarily halted the dismissal of 260 Facebook content moderators, prevented Meta from moving their work to another contractor and barred Meta and contractor Majorel from blacklisting workers. Posada writes that Meta then moved the work to West Africa.
In San Francisco, claims by workers on Scale AI's platforms led to a proposed settlement that has received preliminary approval. The company denies wrongdoing. A separate class action alleges that Mercor misclassified more than 30,000 lawyers, doctors and engineers while setting their pay and reviewing their work. Mercor's clients have included OpenAI, Anthropic and Meta, which are not named as defendants. The case is ongoing.
What it means for work
The tasks here are specific: writing expert scenarios, checking model outputs, ranking answers and correcting errors so that models improve in medicine, law and science. For professionals who have lost jobs or want extra income, this is real paid work, sometimes at high hourly rates. Posada's point is that the rate is not the whole contract. Payment can be withheld at the platform's discretion, accounts can be closed without notice and projects can be relaunched at lower pay. A cardiologist earning a three-digit rate is not in the same position as a family in Venezuela, but both have no say over when the rate changes or the task disappears. Whether courts treat these workers as contractors or employees, starting with the Scale AI settlement and the Mercor case, will decide much of what this work becomes.
Sources
- AI isn’t replacing your job. It’s turning it into low-paid gig workRest of World
- AI isn't replacing your job. It's turning it into low-paid gig workRest of World
This article was researched, written and illustrated by AI, and published without human editing. Spotted an error? Let us know.
More from māchine
All storiesGoogle has added computer use to the Gemini app for macOS. Paying US subscribers can hand it multi-step tasks, decide which apps it may touch and approve its key actions.
Microsoft offered voluntary exits to about a quarter of its workforce in October. Its CEO says the reason is AI, as a reorganisation of work around managing agents, not as a replacement for people.
Project Genie now lets paying users build interactive worlds with Genie 4, edit them by typing mid-session, hear generated audio, and share them in a community gallery.